Myths about Leadership Coaching: Why Every Leader Needs a Coach

Myths about Leadership Coaching

Debunking Common Myths About Leadership Coaching

Myths About Leadership Coaching

Many people believe leaders don't need a coach and have all the knowledge and experience they need to do their job effectively. However, many common myths about leadership coaching need to be debunked. A coach can provide invaluable support and guidance to help leaders develop their skills and reach their goals. In this blog post, we will explore why every leader needs a coach and debunk some of the most common myths about leadership coaching.

Myth #1: Coaches are only for people who are struggling.

Many people believe that coaches are only necessary for leaders who are struggling in their roles. But the truth is, regardless of expertise or experience, every leader can benefit from having a coach.

Coaches are not just for fixing problems or helping leaders who are struggling. They provide valuable support and guidance to help leaders develop their skills, reach their goals, and maximise their potential.

A coach can offer a fresh perspective, challenge assumptions, and provide objective feedback to help leaders become even more effective in their roles.

Whether you are a new leader looking to establish yourself or a seasoned executive wanting to continue your growth, having a coach can be a game-changer. So, don't fall for the myth that coaches are only for those who are struggling. Every leader needs a coach to unlock their full leadership potential.

Myth #2: Coaches are too expensive for most leaders

Many leaders may assume that hiring a coach is a luxury reserved for the wealthy or top executives. However, this is simply not true.

Coaching services come at a cost, but their benefits far outweigh the financial investment. Coaches are skilled professionals who can help leaders enhance their skills, improve their decision-making abilities, and ultimately drive better results for their organisations.

It is important to remember that coaching is an investment in your personal and professional development. Just like any investment, it requires careful consideration and planning. Coaches can work within various budgets and offer flexible payment options, making their services accessible to a wide range of leaders. Furthermore, the return on investment from coaching can be significant, leading to increased productivity, enhanced leadership abilities, and career advancement.

Instead of dismissing coaching as unaffordable, leaders should explore different options and discuss their budget constraints with potential coaches. They may be surprised to find affordable options that can deliver transformative results. In summary, the idea that coaches are too expensive for most leaders is a myth that should be debunked, as the benefits of coaching can far outweigh the initial investment.

Case Example: Enhancing Team Performance and Revenue Growth

Background: Michael Thompson, a sales director at a mid-sized company, faced a challenge. His sales team was underperforming, and employee morale was low. The company's revenue growth had plateaued, and there was pressure from the board to turn things around.

Coaching Intervention: Michael decided to invest in a leadership coach to help him improve his management skills and team performance. The focused work with Michael was specific to his needs in several key areas:

Effective Communication: Michael improved his communication skills, teaching him how to provide clear, constructive feedback and actively listen to his team's concerns.

Strategic Planning: Michael learned to set more effective sales targets and develop strategies to achieve them. He was coached on how to align his team's efforts with the company's broader goals.

Individual Motivation and Engagement: Michael was guided in understanding different motivational techniques, a multidimensional approach to leadership that’s human behaviour-based and how to apply these techniques to his team to boost morale, engagement and outcomes.

Results: Over six months, Michael's team showed significant improvement:

  • Sales Performance: The team's sales figures increased by 28%, directly impacting the company's bottom line.
  • Employee Engagement: Employee satisfaction scores within Michael's team rose, leading to lower turnover rates and reduced recruitment costs.
  • Leadership Skills: Michael's enhanced leadership skills led to better team dynamics, more effective meetings, and streamlined decision-making processes.

ROI Calculation:

Increased Revenue: The 28% increase in sales translated to an additional $2.5 million in revenue.

Cost Savings: Improved employee retention saved the company an estimated $100,000 in recruitment and training costs.

Coaching Investment: The total cost of coaching was $15,000.

Net ROI: The total financial benefit (increased revenue + cost savings) minus the coaching investment equalled a net ROI of $2,585,000.

The other bonus is Michael received a pay rise of over $60K, too.

Myth #3: Coaches are unnecessary for experienced leaders

Experienced leaders often believe that they have reached a level of expertise where they no longer need the guidance of a coach. However, this is a common myth that needs to be debunked. Even the most experienced leaders can benefit from having a coach.

Coaches bring a fresh perspective and can challenge assumptions that may have become ingrained over time. They can help experienced leaders break through any stagnant patterns and push them to achieve even greater heights. An executive coach can provide objective feedback, identify blind spots, and help leaders see things from a different angle.

Experienced leaders may think that they have already learnt all there is to know, but the truth is that leadership is a continuous journey of growth and development. No matter how successful you are, there is always room for improvement. A coach can help experienced leaders stay relevant, adapt to changing circumstances, and develop new skills that can take their leadership to the next level.

In addition, having a coach can provide valuable accountability for experienced leaders. It can be easy for leaders to become complacent or fall into bad habits. A coach can help keep them on track and ensure they continue to challenge themselves and strive for excellence.

So, don't fall for the myth that coaches are unnecessary for experienced leaders. Everyone can benefit from the support, guidance, and accountability that a coach provides, regardless of their level of experience.

Jane: A Story of Rediscovery and Growth

When Jane, a seasoned executive with over 20 years in the tech industry, first considered coaching, she was sceptical. "I thought I had seen it all," Jane recalls. "With decades of experience, what more could I learn?"

But Jane's perspective shifted dramatically after her first few sessions. "Caroline didn't come in with a magic solution. Instead, she asked the right questions, the kind that made me rethink my approach," she says.

One significant turning point was when I challenged Jane to reconsider her leadership style. "Caroline noticed I was often in 'solve-it' mode, jumping in to fix problems myself. It worked, but it wasn't sustainable or empowering for my team. Through coaching, I learned to shift from being a problem-solver to a problem-enabler, guiding and most importantly, orchestrating my team to find solutions independently."

This small but profound change had ripple effects. "My team started taking more initiative and became more accountable. They were more engaged and came up with innovative solutions I hadn't even considered," Jane reflects.

Coaching also helped Jane navigate a major transition in her company. "We were merging with another firm, and the uncertainty was causing a lot of stress in the team. Caroline helped me to lead with empathy and clarity during those turbulent times."

The result?

A smoother transition, a stronger team, and a renewed sense of purpose for Jane. "I realised that no matter how experienced you are, there's always room to grow," she concludes. "Coaching didn't just improve my leadership skills; it rejuvenated my entire outlook on my role and help me deliver substantial results for the business."

Jane's story is a testament to the enduring power of coaching, proving that even the most experienced leaders can find new pathways to growth and effectiveness.

Myth #4: The development of leaders must begin at the top

Many people believe that the development of leaders must begin at the top of an organisation, with executives and senior management leading the way. However, this is not true.

Leadership development should not be limited to those in higher positions but should be encouraged at all levels of an organisation.

When leaders at all levels are given the opportunity to develop their skills and capabilities, it can lead to a more engaged and empowered workforce. By investing in the development of leaders at all levels, organisations can tap into the full potential of their employees. This can result in improved performance, increased innovation, and better decision-making at every level of the organisation. It also allows for a more diverse and inclusive leadership pipeline, where individuals from all backgrounds and positions can contribute to the success of the organisation.

Furthermore, leadership development at all levels can help create a sense of ownership and accountability among employees. When individuals are given the opportunity to develop their leadership skills, they become more invested in the success of the organisation and are more likely to take initiative and make valuable contributions.

Myth #5:  Coaching is Only Valuable Face-to-Face

Many people believe that coaching can only be effective when done in person. With advancements in technology, face to face virtual coaching has become increasingly popular and effective.

Virtual coaching allows leaders to connect with their coaches through face to face video calls, which is like sitting across a desk from each other, but we can be in different countries or states. This allows for flexibility and convenience, as leaders can receive coaching from anywhere in the world.

Virtual coaching offers many benefits, including cost savings, time efficiency, and accessibility. Leaders can schedule coaching sessions at a time that works best for them, without the need to travel or meet in person. This makes coaching more accessible to leaders with busy schedules or those located in remote areas.

In addition, virtual coaching allows leaders to receive support and guidance in real time, regardless of their physical location. This means that leaders can address challenges and receive feedback promptly without having to wait for in-person sessions.

Virtual Coaching: A Case Study

Dani: Leading Across Continents

Dani, a dynamic product manager in a global software company, faced a unique challenge. She led a team that spanned three continents, with members in North America, Europe, and Asia. The diverse time zones and cultural differences made effective leadership an intricate puzzle.

"I felt overwhelmed," Dani admits. "Managing projects across time zones was tough, and I struggled to connect with some team members. I knew I needed help, but with my travel restrictions, traditional face-to-face coaching was out of the question."

That's when she discovered the power of virtual coaching, and Dani started working with Caroline. "The flexibility was a game-changer," she says. "I could schedule sessions around my international meetings, and we used various online tools to collaborate."

I helped Dani develop strategies to bridge her team's cultural and communication gaps. "One of the first things Caroline worked on with me was active listening, asking powerful questions, and understanding the subtle nuances in cross-cultural communication. It was eye-opening. I learned that the more powerful person in the meeting is the one asking the most intelligent questions to influence people."

"The results were remarkable. My team became more cohesive, their project delivery improved, I created a high-performing team that was the envy of my peers, and my team members felt more valued and understood. The CEO also recognised me as one of the most commercially focused product managers. I was offered a promotion to lead the biggest project, which will deliver the business more than 30 million dollars in the next 18 months. Virtual coaching not only helped me overcome the logistical challenges of leading a remote team but also transformed my career and my approach to leadership in a global context," Dani reflects.

Today, Dani is recognised in her company for her innovative approach to remote team management and ability to lead effectively across borders. "Virtual coaching opened up a world of possibilities for me. It wasn't just about overcoming the distance but connecting and leading more effectively, no matter where my team was located."


Coaches can provide valuable guidance and support to all leaders, regardless of their experience or expertise. Coaching is an investment in personal and professional development, and there are options available to suit all budgets and needs. Furthermore, coaching can be as effective virtually, allowing for greater flexibility and convenience. So, don't let the common myths about coaching stop you from unlocking your full leadership potential.

Ready to explore how coaching can transform your leadership? Book a confidential call with Caroline today.

Caroline Kennedy, author of Lead Beyond 2030: The Nine Skills You Need to Intensify Your Leadership Impact, is an accomplished former CEO, Award-Winning Executive Coach and global thought leader on business and leadership. She is a highly sought-after mentor and coach to top global executives. A respected keynote speaker and author, Caroline’s methods are neuroscience-based to achieve rapid development and growth.


Leave a Comment